Voicemail Transcription

phonetag-google-voiceVoicemail is a waste of time. As Michael Arrington said (a while ago), “[v]oicemail is dead. Please tell everyone so they’ll stop using it.” I have no illusions that voicemail will truly die any time soon, so I have tried a number of ways to make voicemail more efficient in my office.

My main solution is voicemail transcription. I use two transcription services: PhoneTag and Google Voice.


If you don’t mind paying, PhoneTag provides excellent transcription, and it will e-mail you an MP3 file of the message along with the transcription. The web interface is a bit dated, but it works perfectly well, and I rarely use it. I prefer getting voicemails by e-mail.

To use PhoneTag, you simply set your phone to forward the call after a certain number of rings, instead of sending it to voicemail. PhoneTag picks up with your greeting, records the message, and transcribes it. You can always access your e-mails from the web interface, or you can have PhoneTag e-mail you a transcription, an audio file, or both. I prefer the latter.

If you wanted to, you could save every voicemail. I usually just delete the e-mails, but it is nice to know I have them sitting on PhoneTag’s server, if I need them.

We pay less than $20 per month for PhoneTag. The cost varies by the number of messages, but PhoneTag does not charge for hangups or messages so garbled it cannot transcribe them at all.

At least until free services like Google Voice catch up with better transcription quality, PhoneTag is well worth the cost.

Google Voice

I also use Google Voice, a free service. Google Voice is like having a personal switchboard. In addition to using it for voicemail transcription, you get a phone number, which Google will redirect to any other numbers according to your instructions. You can set it to screen all calls, certain calls, only pick up calls from a certain group of contacts between 8 and 5 on weekdays, etc. I use my Google Voice number for my “direct line” for this reason, and I forward voicemail from my cell phone to Google Voice so that they also wind up in my e-mail inbox.

The transcription, however, is horrible. Often, I get no clue what the caller was saying from Google’s transcribed version. I assume it will learn over time, but for now, it borders on useless.

For transcription, PhoneTag is the better option right now. But Google Voice may catch up, and when it does, its other features will make it the best option.


  1. Avatar Chris Yeh says:


    I noticed that PhoneTag employs both automated and human-based transcription. Do you restrict PhoneTag to automated only (which PhoneTag says is about 85% accurate), or do you use the human-based transcription?

  2. Sam Glover Sam Glover says:

    I don’t see any option to restrict the transcription to automated only (or any reason to do so), so I assume I am getting some humans. Although if I am, they speak an interesting version of English.

  3. What about using native US English speaking secretaries but at off-shore prices for your document transcription requirements? Our company, based in Israel, employs all US staff but because of their re-location to Israel the pricing is that of an off-shore location. You therefore get real US typists doing the typing at low cost – without any ‘interesting versions of English’ thrown in!

  4. Avatar Heidi Miller says:


    Yeah, I know what you mean. I like the convenience of GoogleVoice, but the transcription can be hilarious! The issue with all automation is that the variances of the human voice are simply far too wide for any automated program to transcribe accurately, no matter how technologically advanced it might be.

    If you’ve ever tried GotVoice’s voicemail transcription, I’d be curious to know what you think of it. We also use automation with correction by humans when the automation gives the transcription a low confidence score. I know a lot of lawyers use the service, but we’re always seeking more feedback.

  5. Avatar MyCaption_Team says:

    Hello Sam — For those who use a PBX or a VoIP phone, MyCaption offers a very compelling voicemail transcription service. It is both accurate and secure. A free trial is available.

  6. Avatar Matt says:

    I’ve used PhoneWire.com voicemail transcription for years. They have absolutely no automation or speech recognition, just live people 24/7. The accuracy I get from them is undeniable. I couldn’t recommend enough people to their solution!

  7. Sam Glover Sam Glover says:

    In the interest of full disclosure, the above commenter left “phonewire.com” as his website address. So while his comments may have merit, they also appear to be biased.

Leave a Reply