On this edition of the Lawyerist podcast, Sam talks to Nicolle Schippers about what legal insurance is and how it can help to bridge the access to justice gap.

Would You Buy an Insurance Policy That Only Pays if You Lose a Case?

Last month, two Florida attorneys launched an insurance company that insures you against losing a case. Sam explained that the idea behind it is that if you are a plaintiff’s lawyer, you purchase a policy on your case, and if you lose the case, the insurance company pays you $100,000. If you win, you pay 7%.

Aaron pointed out that this could certainly lead to some ethics issues where a lawyer could decide to lose and the lawyer would benefit while the client gets nothing. Sam noted, however, that a lawyer could theoretically make an arrangement with a client: turn down the paltry $10,000 settlement offered and allow the lawyer to lose the case, at which point the lawyer would pay the client more money than they would have received in the settlement.

As the cases aren’t vetted, Aaron noted that the big questions here are about the details of coverage. Presumably there is some sort of underwriting, and perhaps there is some sort of contract detailing who can actually receive a payout. Regardless, it is an interesting new option for personal injury attorneys.

Legal Insurance and Bridging the Access to Justice Gap, with Nicolle Schippers

schippers-nicolle-3 USE

Nicolle is the Associate General Counsel and Legal Industry Advocate at ARAG, a legal insurance company, where she has served as counsel for over eight years. In her role at ARAG, in addition to her legal duties, Nicolle manages the Regulatory Compliance and Provider Relations teams and consults on the future of the legal insurance industry. Prior to ARAG, Nicolle worked as a corporate consultant for Nationwide Agribusiness Insurance Company and also served five years in the Air Force as a Judge Advocate General (JAG) during which time she held the roles of criminal prosecutor, family law attorney, claims and tax attorney, and defense counsel.

You can follow Nicolle on LinkedIn.

Thanks to Xero and Abacus for sponsoring this episode!

Support the Podcast

We love our sponsors, but they only cover part of what it costs us to bring you this podcast. So we need your help. If you enjoy the show, please click this button and make a contribution:


Listen and Subscribe

To listen to the podcast, just scroll up and hit the play button (or click the link to this post if you are reading this by email).

To make sure you don’t miss an episode of the Lawyerist Podcast, subscribe now in iTunes, Stitcher, or any other podcast player. Or find out about new episodes by subscribing to the Lawyerist Insider, our email newsletter. We will announce new episodes in the Insider, and you can listen to them right here on Lawyerist.

The Small Firm Scorecard example graphic.

The Small Firm ScorecardTM

Is your law firm structured to succeed in the future?

The practice of law is changing. You need to understand whether your firm is positioned for success in the coming years. Our free Small Firm Scorecard will identify your firm’s strengths and weaknesses in just a few minutes.

Leave a Reply