The Secret Benefits of Coaching Mock Trial

For the past few years, I coached an undergraduate mock trial team. While I stepped down from my role this past September, I am still reaping the benefits of the (unpaid) position. How can coaching mock trial help a newer litigator out?

Rules of Evidence

Sure I took evidence in law school, but I immediately forgot 99% of the rules the moment after I took the exam. Like civil procedure, the rules of evidence make the most sense in context. When you coach undergraduate mock trial, you’re responsible for teaching the rules to non-lawyer undergraduates. I found myself watching Irving Younger in my spare time so that I could copy his moves for my students. I am sure that if/when some of my students attend law school and if/when they watch an Irving Younger video, they will realize that my entire shtick consisted of me channeling Irving Younger. That said, when I teach something, I internalize it (and learn it) more thoroughly. My desire to explain the intricacies of hearsay to my non-lawyer charges drove me to master the rule (probably for the first time).

My newfound mastery of evidentiary procedure had some fun effects. Early in my tenure at my firm, a senior partner mused aloud about an evidentiary question, and I was able to jump in and (citing the rule!) offer an answer. I felt pretty cool. I thanked the mock trial students at our next practice.

Practice Makes Perfect

When you coach mock trial, you spend several weekends judging mock trial. Weekend judging means that you’re not only teaching your students the rules of evidence, you’re presiding as a judge making evidentiary rulings each weekend. You watch students (coached by local attorneys and judges) enter evidence, present opening and closing arguments, object, and impeach witnesses. Now, I’m not saying this is the same thing as watching Edward Bennett Williams conduct a trial each weekend, but you are watching well-trained students go through moves so many times that they become second nature.

I am always jealous when I hear more seasoned attorneys speak of the days when they had a trial every week. Science writer Malcolm Gladwell posits that it takes 10,000 hours of dedicated practice to master a skill. In today’s litigation landscape (unless, of course, you are a public defender or a prosecutor or the like) it could take eons to reach that milestone. Finding ways to access 10,000, hours of practice are few and far between, but I think that coaching mock trial allowed me to add some hours to the clock.

Undergraduates are Awesome

Coaching undergrads will take you back to another time in your life. For me, hanging out with undergraduates forced me to recall a time when I had hours of free time. Last year, one of the mock trial teams created elaborate Facebook profiles for each of the characters in the year’s case (a dramatic affair involving a drunk driving accident). They were hysterical. My own team crafted elaborate demonstratives involving magnets shaped like cups of beer. Each of these seemingly insignificant instances reminded me that free time spurs creativity. A nice reminder in a profession that sometimes can encourage folks to do rather than think.

At the end of the day, the time commitment (two nights a week and weekends) became too much. I am grateful, however, to have invested two years of my life into the endeavor. I know that I learned a lot, and I think the students did as well.

(image: People in a Courtroom from Shutterstock)


  1. Avatar Sumj says:

    Thanks for the help Sybil! Are you ever planning to go back coaching?

  2. Avatar Sybil D. says:

    I hope to! Especially if I can find a way to job share with another attorney . . . maybe this piece will help.

  3. Avatar Ben Weeks says:

    Sybil Dunlop is the best blogger on Lawyerist. Hands down.

  4. Sam Glover Sam G. says:

    I didn’t coach mock trial, but I taught appellate writing and advocacy through the moot court program at my alma mater. My experience was similar. There’s no better way to learn than by teaching. That’s somewhat ironic, I suppose, but it’s true.

  5. Avatar Jo says:

    I completely agree with you. I helped coach a middle school team and still got the same benefits you did. I also make sure to volunteer as a judge anytime there’s a mock trial or moot court competition. Each time that I take part in judging (or coaching), I learn so much and am so inspired .

  6. Avatar Sadie says:

    This kind of volunteering sounds insanely boring to me, but I think it’s cool that you make/made time for it and got so much out of the experience.

Leave a Reply