Freezing Anonymous Online Speech

Start spreadin’ the news. Websites will be leaving New York soon. While personally I tend to like the idea of making anonymous comment spam illegal, New York’s recently proposed bills to ban anonymous online speech, seem like good old-fashioned overreaching to me:

21 2. A WEB SITE ADMINISTRATOR UPON REQUEST SHALL REMOVE ANY COMMENTS
22 POSTED ON HIS OR HER WEB SITE BY AN ANONYMOUS POSTER UNLESS SUCH ANONY-
23 MOUS POSTER AGREES TO ATTACH HIS OR HER NAME TO THE POST AND CONFIRMS
24 THAT HIS OR HER IP ADDRESS, LEGAL NAME, AND HOME ADDRESS ARE ACCURATE.
25 ALL WEB SITE ADMINISTRATORS SHALL HAVE A CONTACT NUMBER OR E-MAIL
26 ADDRESS POSTED FOR SUCH REMOVAL REQUESTS, CLEARLY VISIBLE IN ANY
27 SECTIONS WHERE COMMENTS ARE POSTED.


The purpose of the bill, as reported by the Guardian article, quoting Assemblyman Jim Conte at Lipolitcs, who co-sponsored the bill, is to combat cyber-bullying:

With more and more people relying on social media and the internet to communicate and gather information, it is imperative that the legislature put into place some type of safeguard to prevent people from using the Internet’s cloak of anonymity to bully our children and make false accusations against local businesses and elected officials.

And of course the natural solution to protect our children, businesses and elected officials is to make a law that abridges the right of people to speak freely online.

Wait, did he say elected officials? Yeah, I’ve always thought political speech is too nasty. Let’s clean it up.

One might assume that, as a graduate of State University of New York at Stony Brook with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Economics and Political Science, Assemblyman Conte might have stumbled upon the document that binds us all. But then again, you know what they say about assumptions.

And here’s NYS Senator Tom O’Mara eloquently expressing his support:

And setting aside the seemingly clear violation of the 1st Amendment issue, there are of course the practical ramifications.

Since the onus is placed on the website administrator to remove anonymous comments upon request, the likely outcome will be that many website admins will simply shut-down comments to their sites altogether.

And what about online surveys? And as Columbia law school professor, Tim Wu, told the Guardian, online course evaluations?

But assuming these bills become law, the most obvious outcome seems to be that people just won’t register and admin websites in the state of New York. Which is great news for the development industry in New Jersey!

But of course these are only a few of the practical consequences of this important legislation. I’m sure you can think of some more.

Perhaps PC Magazine’s Damon Poeter (@dpoeter) puts it best: Proposed NY Ban on Anonymous Commenting So Stupid it Hurts

Author requests that all comments to this article be made anonymously.

Subscribe

Get Lawyerist in Your Inbox, Daily

Current Articles
Current Lab Discussions
  • shg

    Cool story, bro. Not like I didn’t post about this three weeks ago, but hey, even old news is new if you’re this far behind the curve.

    • Gyi

      Cool troll, bro. Constructive as always.

      • shg

        Sorry that I didn’t rub your belly, li’l fella, but it’s more constructive than you think. Maybe you’ll elevate your game rather than write crap in the hope that no one will notice or call you on it. No need to thank me for being the mean old man. It’s my pleasure.

        • More than one blog/blogger is allowed to write about a story, even if it is no longer breaking news.

        • Gyi

          You might not believe it, but I am usually actually very appreciative of your critiques.

          But in this particular instance, I don’t think the web was polluted by an additional post on an important issue.

          Think my post sucked? Fine. Accusing me of being behind the curve because I wrote about something that you wrote about a few weeks ago? C’mon man.

          • shg

            It’s one thing to be late. It’s another to be superficial. It’s another to be way late. It’s another to be way late and superficial. Try not to be. Do it for the children.

            And Sam, Generalissimo Francisco Franco is still dead. Just sayin’.