After years of using Windows, I recently did what I regularly advise others to do: I bought a Mac. So far, it’s been great, and to my surprise, relatively painless. I have had to solve a few problems, but none particularly difficult.
For Windows users interested in switching, here’s why I switched, what’s awesome about my new Mac, and what I miss about Windows.
Why I bought a Mac
Except for my high school photography and journalism classes, I have always used Windows PCs. Despite all the hype coming from Cupertino, Windows has always “just worked” just fine for me. So, unlike many misguided switchers, I did not decide to buy a Mac because of an ignorant impression that Macs are faster or more secure or even easier to use (for a proficient user, anyway). I guess I bought a Mac mostly because I was getting bored with Windows. Besides, my iPad has been a great experience, as has my recently-purchased iPhone 5. (Also: beautiful hardware.) Whatever the main motivation, when Windows 8 failed to impress me (and annoyed me a lot), I ordered a Mac mini.
First, the jury is still out on whether I have “switched” to Mac. I’m using one, and that is all. I still have Windows 7 on my ThinkPad and on my Dell desktop, both of which I still use frequently. That said, my Mac will be my primary computer for the foreseeable future.
What I like about my new Mac
I am not generally wowed by speed. A new computer had better feel way faster than an old one, as a general rule. Still, I am impressed by all the go-fast bits Apple squeezed into this little container. It has a quad-core Intel Core i7 processor, and I maxed out the memory at 16 GB (I ordered a Crucial memory kit, though; I’m not paying Apple’s ridiculous memory prices). The 1 TB Fusion drive is one part speedy solid-state drive, and one part regular spinning platters. Everything is satisfactorily zippy. (I paid well for this, of course; my Mac mini was just under $1,300.)
The only real sacrifice, as far as I can tell, is the graphics. Apple is now using Intel’s integrated graphics instead of a separate graphics processor. It’s fast enough for me, though, and it works very well for wasting time playing Minecraft. If I ever become a hardcore PC gamer, I will get a suped-up Windows rig, anyway, so whatever I’m missing out on in the graphics department is not missed.
But really, the hardware is just a different box to set on my desk. The real difference comes from using it, and that means OS X.
Getting along with a Mac
I don’t like running emulators or virtualization, if I can avoid it, so I am trying to stick with native software. It has not been difficult. Most of my work is done in Google Chrome, Microsoft Office, or Evernote, and all are available for Mac. In fact, Evernote for Mac is nicer than its Windows sibling. I cannot say the same for Office for Mac 2011, however.
Office for Mac 2011 has almost nothing in common with Office for Windows or with any other software written for OS X. Instead, it exists on its own with a clumsy user interface. It works fine, even if it is not pleasant to work with. I have not had any problems creating or editing documents and sharing them with Windows users.
I have a copy of Acrobat for Mac, but I didn’t bother to install it until very recently. It was easy enough to find and install the ScanSnap software for Mac, and I found that it works just fine without Acrobat installed. Since OS X’s built-in Preview software does some basic PDF editing, I probably could have gotten along without Acrobat indefinitely.
I have not installed QuickBooks yet. I am trying to decide whether to switch to the Mac version or the cloud version, QuickBooks Online. But either way, I know it will work just fine. Although just like Office, I have heard the Mac version of QuickBooks leaves much to be desired.
It is obvious that designing software for OS X is fundamentally different than designing software for Windows. Companies that get that, like Evernote, make software that is a pleasure great to use on both systems. Companies that don’t, like Microsoft and Intuit, have me looking for native Mac alternatives, or else cloud-based options.
One of my favorite thing about Macs is the prevalence of keyboard shortcuts. This is a system that favors the mouse and trackpad, but leaves all the keyboard shortcuts in place, too. That means you can type things you use all the time, like em dashes, the ¶ and § symbols, and much more, just by using Option and Option+Shift plus the appropriate key. On a Windows PC, you have to memorize complicated Alt codes, which only work in some software, or set up shortcuts in Word that aren’t available in anything else. (You can also use text expanders, of course, which is what I do in Windows.) Legal writing is sometimes easier on a Mac, due to the ease of accessing special characters.
What I miss about Windows
There are not many things I miss about Windows, actually. And the things I do miss are probably low on most users’ lists. I miss being able to FTP into my websites from Windows Explorer. When I try in Finder, I can’t upload any files. I don’t like using traditional FTP tools, which are clumsy, as a rule, and I liked this easy shortcut when I needed to quickly get files on or off my websites.
I also miss the wide variety of free software available for Windows. I have used the free Notepad++ as my primary text editor for years, but I couldn’t find a good free text editor for OS X. Not one with code highlighting, anyway. Eventually, I spent $50 on BBedit. I’m not sorry, since it is a very good text editor, but I don’t feel like it is $50 better than Notepad++.
There are also a couple of things I thought I would have to do without, but I found solutions as good or better than what Windows offers.
Aero Snap
One of my favorite features of Windows 7 was the Aero Snap feature, which makes it simple to resize windows so they take up half the screen. All you have to do is drag a window to the left or right edge, and it will resize itself to take up half the screen. I use this feature constantly in Windows.
In OS X, resizing windows is a lot more fiddly. You can finally drag from the edges, instead of just the lower-right corner, but it’s still a pain to get two documents to take up half the screen apiece. Fortunately, there is BetterSnapTool, which brings Aero Snap to OS X, plus some additional features, like resizing to quarters and sixths, if you want. There are a few other utilities that do this, but I went with BetterSnapTool because it offers the most features and the best price.
AutoHotKey
A lot of the typing I do winds up being repetitive. Like signature blocks, HTML link tags, our weekly top posts roundup and other stuff. Plus, I really like having access to special characters like en dashes and em dashes without memorizing Alt codes. On Windows, AutoHotKey makes this pretty simple.
But on OS X and iOS, TextExpander is even better. Unlike AutoHotKey, a scripting tool, TextExpander has an actual interface that makes it easy to create text snippets. Of course, it is not as powerful as AutoHotKey, either, but I wasn’t using all the fancy features, anyway. I also love being able to sync up my text snippets with my iPhone and iPad.
What I don’t like about my new Mac
Apart from badly-adapted software like Office and QuickBooks, the keyboard is both a pleasure to use (see above) and a complete pain. I’ll never understand why it requires finger contortion just to copy and paste using the keyboard. Or why it takes two keys to get to the end of a line, but only one to get to the end of a document. Or why there is no forward delete key on the wireless keyboard. Or why the Home and End keys work differently in Office than in everything else, kind of like Shift+Delete in bbEdit, which screwed me up all the time until I figured out how to turn it off.
In the user interface, it bugs me that I cannot cut and paste files; I have to open two Finder windows and drag the files from one to the other, which requires quite a few additional steps. Or that I cannot administer files through a file open/save dialog.
But really, those are fairly minor quibbles. I have gotten used to the keyboard and its inconsistent behavior, and I have gotten used to the different ways the interface functions.
Should you switch?
I cannot think of any compelling reason to switch to Mac. As I have always said, there are good things and bad things about the Apple ecosystem, but in the end, it’s just a different computer.
Now that I have a Mac myself, though, I cannot think of any compelling reason not to get one. My migration has been relatively easy, and I none of the problems I have had took more than remedial computer knowledge to overcome.
So if you are interested in switching, go ahead. You will probably be glad you did (confirmation bias and all). If not, you will be just fine using what you have now.




Read the comments below or add one of your own.
Next Comments →
For those looking for a less expensive text editor with code highlighting I suggest Smultron. It can be acquired from the App Store for roughly $5. It does not have as many features as BBEdit, but it covers the basics for a reasonable cost of entry.
Talking of editors with code highlighting, Sublime Text would be a better alternative wouldn’t it ? :)
For aerosnap functions and really nice keyboard shortcut tweaking, you might want to give BetterTouchTool a shot. It’s free, too.
And if you want to really have fun with your keyboard, try Alfred. Version 2 is almost out (I’ve been beta testing it), but V1 is awesome too. The powerpack is worth it just for the file-management.
Finally, XtraFinder. It gives you cut/copy for files, tabbed browsing, putting directories on top… also free.
Between those three, there is almost nothing I miss about Windows. Except for “keep window on top.” It was really nice to put a small video player in the corner of the screen, floating above all the other windows, while I worked on something else.
OK, maybe not that hard but it’s been neither easy nor satisfying. I blame my iPhone for getting me into this. I’ve been on the iMac 16gb about 6 months now. The OS may be elegant but how does that help the user when the file system is hideous?
Everything about this Mac screams: “you are a stupid user just let me do it for you!” Programs do what they want to do effortlessly. If I have my own ideas, I must get ready for a fight.
Microsoft Office is central to so many operations, it’s more than inconvenient that the Mac versions are lame.
The wireless keyboard is slick, its’ lack of a 10-keypad is unforgivable. I guess the brilliant graphic designers who like these so much are above working with numbers. Also no reasonable excuse for leaving off PgUp/Dn. Or fwd delete.
For what I paid for this thing I could have had two screaming Windows notebooks. Needless to say, the Apple “no return” policy took effect the moment I broke the seal on the box.
I don’t recommend the conversion to anyone.
If you don’t mind shelling out some cash, Coda 2 comes in on top as the best text editor on the market for any operating system. The interface is beautiful, and FTP and editing is combined seamlessly – you’ll never work another day in your life.
Just a few recommendations to make your crossover a little more permanent. Get Open Office for your word processing / csv needs. I’m sure you’ve heard of it and maybe even used it before, it’s my word processor of choice to avoid Microsofts clumsy Office for Mac. Also for a text editor, if you’re still looking for a free one, try Sublime Text. Hope you enjoy your Mac experience.
OpenOffice.org, I think you mean, not Open Office. In any case, LibreOffice is the one to get, now.
I’ve stopped using OOo/LibreOffice, since preserving formatting is too important to me, and I frequently have to exchange Office documents with clients.
I went Mac 2.5 yrs. ago (iMac 21″ w/ 1TB HD/ 12GB RAM) and have never looked back, though as you note it’s not perfect. I agree that OpenOffice has too many formatting incompatibilities with Word to make it seamlessly useful. I have to run Windows on my Mac for a couple of office (govt) apps and for Quicken (Q for Mac sucks so hard it’s not funny), but only for that, and I got MS Office Student for that work use.
So what you’re saying is that you use OSX for web browsing, and dual boot Windows when you actually have things you need to do due to a better user experience?
“I cannot think of any compelling reason not to get a Mac”. Well, this is just a reminder that the price difference is a factor for many of us slobs on this side of the tracks. I work in the public sector and my office will not switch over to Macs ever, or at least not in my lifetime. I work on many of the same files in both locations, and I don’t have any interest in making that more complex. That being said, next time I need to replace a machine, if Windows 8 is going to be forced upon me, I might have to reconsider my position.
You misread (and mis-copied) that sentence. What I wrote was that I cannot think of any compelling reason to get a Mac. I was just pointing out that it’s not hard to switch, if you do decide to get one.
Sam, I got my quote from the next paragraph down.
Great article. I’m a long-time Mac user but have to run Windows in virtualization for a few programs.
Most Mac v. PC articles are written by fanboys or haters on either or both sides. I found this article to be what most aren’t- honest and fair.
Good job.
I have been a Mac user for four years and like it very much. I am a heavy user because of my many software development projects and Virtual Machines.
There are several tasks that require Windows and I need a Windows VM to complete the work. I have not found a good replacement to Visio and MS project. Aside from those, I am very happy. Cost is a factor to consider though
I suggest you look at OmniGroup’s products. OmniGraffle blows away MS Visio and OmniPlan is a very good native Mac competitor to MS Project. I use and love both products (and OmniFocus as well, if you’re looking for a GTD app). OmniGroup has released compelling iOS apps as companions to the full-featured OS X products, and new versions of the desktop apps are in the works for later this year.
I can’t believe that the author paid $50 for BBEdit and complained about the lack of a good free text editor when the makers of BBEdit also make TextWrangler, which is among the best free text editors I’ve used on any platform. I do share his lament for Microsoft Office though — it’s good enough to serve as my sole office suite, but it is indeed frustrating to use at times.
Good article! I made the switch last month – so far so good. I opted for the “One2One” support and have found it to be a big help. MacBook Air is fast and like all Apple tech, well designed and easy on the eye. Ramp time is faster than I thought it would be. Only thing I miss is Outlook for e-mail and calendar.
I run Win7, Win Server, SQL, IIS (typical corporate type software) virtualized on an iMac. Actually works much better than it did on my old Dell. Response time is faster (in Windows), swapping virtual images to other windows machines is breeze and all backups go to Time Machine which is super easy to work with. Each O/S has it’s pro’s and con’s. Mac will never (I’ve learned never say never but at least for the near term) take the corporate world by storm. That means for pro users that run specialized software there’s really no other choice than going the Windows route. Nothing wrong with that, that’s just how it is.
Consumers, on the other hand that just browse the net, listen to music, watch movies, etc. a Mac is an easy option. I’m just speaking for me, but I’ve found Apple’s mojo (once they got you in their tent) is their ecosystem. Purchase of books, software, music, even product purchases at the Apple store all go through your Apple ID account. It makes life very simple and that a nice bonus. Biggest benefit I’ve seen is the shelf life of the machine. It’s great. I’m not sure why, maybe the Dells I bought were just bad quality but it seems like I always had to replace those every 2yrs.
After only using PCs for some 20 years, I finally bought a 13″ MBP (2008) in 2009. I hated the chickelet-keyboard for 1 day, now I love it. The build quality, especially the screen is 10x better than any laptop I even got from corporate America. Now I have a 17″ MBP (2011) which has the quad i7 and 16 GB RAM and a hybrid-drive. I can run everything all the time if I wish, including powerful virtualized environments with many virtual machines. With VMWare Fusion 5 which can finally access my discrete GPU even my 3-D games look great and are very playable in massive online player environments! I know you are paying more for a MBP with “comparable” features, but that only tells you half the story! Pay up for quality! And your EYES will thank you!
For code editing I use Komodo Edit. It is free and works like a champ. I switched from Windows to Mac two years ago and I will never go back. My home network was a pain under Windows. When I went to Mac everything just worked.
Hi Sam,
I was a windows user for over 15 years before I can to my senses and switched to a Mac. I was tired of spending the first 30 minutes of my day troubleshooting why my pc had frozen yet again. I now only use my macs for work and and one pc running windows 7 to support my customers.
I would recommend the switch to anyone who is tired of windows. I also recommend OpenOffice.org instead of office for the Mac. And there are tons of good free software at the apple App Store.
I even use the Mac (I now have 3 iMacs and a MacBook) and use them for everything. One of those iMacs is even a server. It is so simple even to setup a server because the Mac itself and OSX are simple. I have found so many times that I tried too hard to do something that was so simple.
I know lots of people who switched to Mac but I don’t know anyone who switched back. I wish you all the best and welcome to the Mac.
Regards,
Pietro Iglio, Pietro-Tech
Good article, I bought a MBA ( the cool way to say Mac Book Air) this past summer and use Win 7 on it, love it. Cost was a couple hundred more than a comparable ultabook, but got a great piece of hardware, with windows and MountainLion! So far my favorite computer ever.
This is a great article documenting the journey of switching to a Mac after being a long time Microsoft Windows user.
I bought my first Mac, a Macbook Pro running MacOS X 10.6.8, in March 2011, to develop my iPhone Apps Development hobby, and have published three apps on the App Store. The XCode development environment and the ease of testing Apps in the simulator and my iPod Touch add to the enjoyment of the hobby, although I’ve made almost nothing from the Apps.
My Mac has become my primary PC for Internet Usage, Music Collections, and Photo Storage. I also use it to watch movies with my headphones.
Being an information technology professional, I have Oracle VirtualBOX installed with virtual machines running Microsoft Windows 2000 and Linux. The virtual machines run at a reasonable performance for me to use my Microsoft Windows software on the Microsoft Windows VM and try software stacks in the Linux VM.
Also, working commercially with UNIX as an administrator and supporting UNIX-hosted system environments, I really like the command line interface running Bourne Again Shell (BASH) that is available on Linux and UNIX.
Migrating my photo collection to iPhoto was an interesting experience, and for me, it required thought to organise my photos into folders representing events before I imported it. Using this method of importing photos into iPhoto has made navigating the photo library easy.
Adapting to iTunes from Microsoft Windows Media Player required me to alter my thinking. In Microsoft Windows Media Player, I thought of my music collection in terms of folders. In iTunes, for me to get the best usage, I’ve adopted the thinking that my music library is a massive bucket of music placed into it, and views (playlists) need to be created to restrict the view of the library to a specific criteria. Once I adopted this thinking, I am able to use the Playlist criteria’s feature to define the playlists I want, or simply drag the music into the playlist.
Since having my Macbook Pro, I’ve got into the habit of using the Backup/Restore utility, known as Time Machine. Time Machine is so easy to use. Choose a portable hard drive that will be dedicated to backing up the machine, insert it into the Mac, click the Time Machine backup icon, and away it goes. I’ve chosen a portable hard drive that has double the capacity of the Macbook Pro’s internal hard drive.
Please note that I remain to have my Asus F3F Dual-core 1.73GHz laptop with 3GB RAM running Microsoft Windows 7 Professional. I use it for Microsoft Office usage and graphic art work since I’ve built up a large collection of tools since the 1990s and 2000s. I also use it for Microsoft Access and Microsoft Visual Studio Express tasks.
Strong qualities of using Microsoft Windows 7 I miss are:
- Windows Explorer’s File System Navigation Versatility: The Finder is quite restrictive for me, as I am used to copy/pasting folder paths and pasting them into the Windows Explorer Address Bar. I would like to see this feature added to Finder;
- Free Tool: 7-ZIP – Since 7-ZIP is open source, I’d like to see Finder have the ability to offer 7-ZIP compression, in addition to using standard ZIP compression;
- Free Tool: Active ISO Burner – I don’t like using the Disk Utility to burn ISO images to CD/DVD, as another reason I bought my Macbook Pro is to not use the System Utilities menu (yes, I like to switch off being a techo on my weekends, except when developing my Apps);
- Microsoft Access with VBA: Microsoft Access is a great standalone encapsulated tool to automate tasks related to data and have the code contained within, for specific project-related tasks;
- Microsoft Internet Explorer: Some corporate web portals require Microsoft Internet Explorer 8+ to offer critical functionality; and
- Crappy Printer Support: Yes, I have a really cheap wi-fi printer that is reliable in usage from my Microsoft Windows 7 machine, and doesn’t seem to work so great from MacOS X 10.6.8. It’s probably due to a lazy user set-up, as I can be lazy when it comes to PCs at home, but the drivers produced by the vendor (and I will refrain from names) don’t appear well-developed for Mac OS X as they do for Microsoft Windows. I also had my cheap printer one year before I bought the MacBook Pro.
Macs are for folks who know nothing about computers. It’s an appliance. They drive Toyota Camrys and Honda Accords.
PCs are for folks who understand what a hot rod is. They drive Dodge Charger RTs and Fiat Abarths.
LOL no.
No, I used to build and run PCs for 15 years, switched to Mac 3 years ago and got rid of my last windows machine yesterday (it had been in the cupboard for 2 years). Oh, and btw, I drive a 23-yr old Porsche 928 as my daily driver. I wouldn’t touch a Camry or Prius even if given to me for free…:-)
For a free code completion app, try TextWrangler, a free version of BBEdit from the same developers (obviously with some advanced features stripped out).
Also, you can copy and paste files in Finder. You can also use the spring-loaded folders feature which is quite amazing. Finder-based CUT and paste, though, doesn’t work natively however.
Lastly, I’m not sure what you mean by finger contortion in Mac for copy and paste via keyboard. Historically speaking, Mac invented keyboard-based copy and paste using the X, C & V keys. Cmd-C was the original copy. Since Microsoft lacked a Cmd key on their keyboards, they simply remapped it to Ctrl. Give it a few months and you, like me, might find copying and pasting on a PC to be finger contortion.
Glad to hear you are getting along. A few notes:
1. I use Word and Excel docs all the time, but fortunately haven’t touched MS Office in years. Instead I use Apple’s iWork, which reads and writes MS docs just fine. For those times where the formatting gets screwed up or the spreadsheet is really complex, I use Libre Office.
2. In my opinion, there are much better text editors than BBEdit. Check out SubLime Text 2 and the new TextMate 2 Alpha, which recently went open source.
3. Copy/paste of files in finder works just fine using the standard command-C and command-V keyboard shortcuts (at least in Mountain Lion which is what I’m using.)
Copy/paste works fine. I want to cut and paste.
Sam,
Try this when copying files:
Highlight the files you want to copy (list mode or icon).
Top Finder drop down – and Copy.
Yes, move to your second window at selected folder.
Top of Finder – Paste.
Drag and drop works probably faster.
A really cool trick I remember at a Graphics meeting,
If you want to drag a picture from the Finder to your WProc.
or InDesign, etc., drag the file to the icon’s open App.
Wait for the program to come to the front, then, drop the file at the insertion point!
If you are doing text work, dragging your ‘Sunday’ editorial for your weekly
Editorial (on Thursday – different readers :), this option may work.
Used Macs since … ’88.
Understand the frustration with admin files when opening or saving.
I do a lot of save as – for copying a current file.
A quick Word trick:
When closing many files in Word, hold down Option before clicking on File,
Close all will appear.
Walah, all will close at once! Be ready.
Same for Save – hold down Option before clicking.
If all are saved, it’s really nice. If not, MS will ask to save the ones you edited.
Welcome to the Apple family,
Mr. Kerry Kennard
In the user interface, it bugs me that I cannot copy and paste files; I have to open two Finder windows and drag the files from one to the other, which requires quite a few additional steps. Or that I cannot administer files through a file open/save dialog.
How long did you look for the many free UNIX > MacOSX ports available? The world is flooded with them. Just like you found them on your PC, they just didn’t float to your computer.
I worked at a major TV network for about 10 years and was partly responsible for all the computers: about 300 half Mac and half PC. One day one of the IT staff came to me complaining about the Macs. So, I had him bring me all the documentation on the Macs and PC expenses. I had ONE repair bill for a Mac HD and almost NO labor. However, for the PCs we had about 3 FTEs for repairing PCs for the year (6000 hours). I told him to shut up, go back to his office and be glad I did not replace all PCs with Macs and eliminate his department.
What you will find is that in the long run, for an enterprise, Macs are much less expensive as a business computer. Don’t like the Mac version of Office? Get Open Office. Personally, I’ve not used much PC software that isn’t clunky. Personally, I like Office better on the Mac, but I don’t like MS Office on any platform.
Really? You are having trouble with keyboard commands? Mac’s keyboard shortcuts are almost all easier. Again, I find a PC clunky. We have several PCs. I have had staff tell me they want their Mac back.
It will not take much time and you will love your Mac!
Next Comments →