Why You Should (?) Renew Your Bar Association Membership

A couple of weeks ago, I asked why I ought to renew my bar association membership. Well, July 1st was the renewal date, and I decided to let it go. Then I had breakfast with Eric Cooperstein, who is making his way up my local bar’s leadership ladder, and he tried to change my mind. His reasoning was that the bar is like the nexus of the legal community.

In a similar vein, Jim Dedman responded to my post at NC Law Blog, arguing that the bar association is a sort of last redoubt for camaraderie among lawyers:

There was, it seems, a fellowship – a camaraderie of sorts – in the profession which transcended the side of the bar on which a given attorney practiced. Sure, part of that may be the product of that wistful haze of nostalgia, but there’s some truth to the notion that lawyers knew each other better before the days we could all hide behind our monitors, iPhones, and email addresses.

Perhaps we’ve forgotten what it’s like to sit in a room in a non-adversarial setting with our potential lawyer adversaries and opposing counsel. There’s nothing wrong with socializing with the other side of the bar, talking about the state of the law, and learning from each other. It seems that in the fast paced nature of today’s practice, we’ve lost that, which is a shame, because that type of interaction could forestall petty discovery disputes that could occur in the future.

In many jurisdictions, those rosters meetings and docket calls – where so many lawyers would get to know one another – are relics of the past. Many lawyers never see the inside of a courtroom anymore. So, perhaps, membership in one’s state and local bar association might facilitate at least some of that contact and engender friendships with those across the bar or outside your practice area. That wouldn’t be such a bad thing, now, would it?

I like the idea, but I’m not convinced that’s what bar associations are actually doing. I’ve actually been quite involved in my state bar association since I got my license. I’ve been on several committees, attended CLEs, gone to benefits and happy hours, and so on. But instead of community and camaraderie, I felt like the bar was either asking for my money, my time, or just promoting networking. That’s not the same thing as community and camaraderie at all.

There are certainly some tangible benefits to joining the bar association, like discounts on legal research, health insurance, etc., but those are purely transactional. If bar associations are trying to compete on value, they are going to lose, because most of us can find equally-good (or better) deals elsewhere. And in any case, coupons don’t feel like a compelling reason to stick around.

Eric and Jim are talking about intangibles. Or less-tangibles, anyway. Building community and camaraderie are compelling reasons to stick around. If friends and mentors are members, lawyers are far more likely to remain members. If bar associations want to compete on intangibles like community and camaraderie, I’d be more interested in renewing my own membership, but I’d like to see some evidence they are actually trying.

[via Abnormal Use]

(photo: http://www.flickr.com/photos/niallkennedy/40727794/)

Legal Careers, Lifestyle

, ,

  • David

    There are states that have no Bar and no Bar dues.

  • Roy Ginsburg

    Sam,

    Would you consider building relationships very similar to building community and camaraderie? I do. I have a strong professional relationship with both you and Eric. And I can confidently state that it grew strong through Bar activities. Of course, there were other activities as well, but Bar stuff played a large role.

    • http://lawyerist.com/author/samglover/ Sam Glover

      Let’s go ahead and assume that our CLE provider and bar association are one and the same, as they are in many states. Teaching CLE seminars has definitely been a good way for me to connect with other lawyers and build relationships. But while CLE can be a part of building community and camaraderie, I don’t think it’s anywhere near the center.

  • http://www.lawpracticematters.com Erik Mazzone

    Interesting discussion. One key way bar associations help with camaraderie and community building is through participation in shared projects. Working collaboratively on a project builds relationships and community organically.

    CLE programs are one kind of shared project, but as Roy references above there are others – the very act of leading a bar association as a volunteer is a shared project. Public service and pro bono projects (Wills for Heroes, Law Related Education, Ask a Lawyer programs, etc.) and section/committee participation are also common sources of shared projects in many bar associations.

    Like a lot of lawyers, I’m not a natural born networker. Business development did not come easily to me and I was very uncomfortable with it when I was new in private practice. I wish I knew then how easy the many shared projects of bar association work would make it to meet people and build relationships.

  • http://www.PAinjurycase.com Dave S

    I’m a member of the County and State Bar Associations. I have done some selected things, including serving as an Arbitrator through the County Bar. But, I haven’t gotten the feeling that there is much camaraderie. Dunno, maybe if I committed more time? As a younger lawyer, I always felt like I was pledging a fraternity again or starting law school again when I went to bar association functions. By now, I’ve decided that there is only so much time you have to devote and I’ve chosen to do it in other groups, particularly Rotary, which has been a really good experience. The lawyers that I like, I deal with them directly on a personal level.